Compass Box – 15 not out

8 Comments on Compass Box – 15 not out

Compass Box has long been one of my favourite blenders. Founded by whiskymaker John Glaser in 2000, it has gone from strength to strength. The team has been at the forefront of innovation, and is currently campaigning for more transparency in regulations following a recent run-in with the Scotch Whisky Association, which you can find more about on, which broke the story. Five years after his last appearance at Vinopolis, we welcomed John back to host a special 15th anniversary tasting.

John Glaser vs SWA

Up for a fight. Compass Box’s John Glaser wants the law changed on transparency in whisky

In their own words – John Glaser

‘We’ve always told people the ages in our blends, the distilleries in the recipes, the types of casks used; we’re completely transparent about our raw materials. People want to know, they have a right

We don’t know who reported us to the Scotch Whisky Association, or why. We can guess, though!’

‘We believe fundamentally that a whisky producer ought to have the freedom to tell people what is in the blend – not necessarily an obligation, but a right’

‘The first Spice Tree was banned because the Scotch Whisky Association said the technique we were using [extra wood staves suspended in a cask] wasn’t traditional. After many meetings, my final argument was “this is about quality”. Their response was “John, to us, quality is irrelevant“!’

‘I started in the wine trade and moved to whisky and worked for a small Scotch whisky brand you may have heard of called Johnnie Walker

‘My first office was under a women’s hairdresser in Marylebone – we shared a bathroom’

‘I decided to begin with something people weren’t familiar with, so I started with grain whisky. Grain whisky is much lighter than malt; a purer, cleaner spirit – it doesn’t mean one is better than the other, they’re just different’

‘Stupidly I named my first blended malt Eleuthera after the Bahamian island – you get it? No? Exactly! My father told me it was a ridiculous name…

‘I looked at using Japanese whiskies years ago before it was cool. We’ve been playing around with bourbon, rye and other spirits – the blend between Mezcal and Scotch didn’t work!’

Compass Box tasting line-up

The Compass Box tasting line-up

We tasted

  • Hedonism – the first expression Compass Box bottled on October 23 2000, a light and creamy blended grain.
  • Eleuthera, First Release – John’s first blended malt, released in 2002 using whisky from Caol Ila and Clynelish. Rich, sweet and smoky.
  • The Peat Monster – the peated entry in the Signature Range. A superb digestif that works well with blue cheese.
  • The Spice Tree – finished in casks with toasted new French oak heads, this is a blend of Clynelish, Dailuaine and Teaninich.
  • Flaming Heart, 2015 Edition – the 15th anniversary bottling combines Speyside and Highland malts aged in new French oak with peated whisky from Islay. Sweet, spicy and lightly smoky.
  • This is Not a Luxury Whisky – inspired by René Magritte’s 1920s painting The Treachery of Images, this combination of sherried Glen Ord, Caol Ila, and grain from Girvan and Strathclyde is complex, full-bodied, rich, sweet and smoky – a delight. It tastes luxury to me…
  • Hedonism Quindecimus – the final whisky was the special 15th anniversary edition of the first. A sumptuous blend of grain whiskies, this was full of tropical-fruit flavours with the trademark Hedonism creaminess.

The tasting concluded with a pair of experiments: firstly a Caol Ila at two-and-a-half years old and around 57%, which was fiery but very drinkable, followed by Scovados, a blend of Spice Tree and Calvados – definitely a work in progress, but you could see the thinking behind the classic combination of fruity apple and spicy cinnamon.


Imyril @Imyril
This is Not a Luxury Whisky – Ceci n’est pas un whisky de luxe. Ceci est un whisky extraordinaire. #twetasting @compassbox

To relive the tasting as it happened on Twitter, you can read our Storify post.

Whisky of the night

It is strange how different whiskies seem to change in taste based on mood, temperature and many other factors. On the night, the whole room was almost unanimous that The Spice Tree showed particularly well. However, Hedonism is always my favourite.
Compass Box Hedonism

Nose: Intense vanilla and coconut with hints of nutmeg and mango.

Palate: Rich and creamy. Vanilla is dominant, with pineapple, black pepper, cherry and cinnamon in the background.

Finish: Medium to long, creamy vanilla is there at the very end, continuing the theme from the first nosing.

Comment: A superb example of grain whisky. This is light and easy drinking, a great choice for first dram of the day, but with enough complexity to keep me interested whenever I drink it. It is sad that grain whisky is rarely seen and often underappreciated, as while it keeps the prices lower, it offers many hidden gems.

Every whisky showed well on the night, with skilful blending as evident in the Eleuthera as it was in this year’s limited editions. If you’ve yet to try any Compass Box whiskies, we have this excellent ‘test-tube’ set of five miniatures of the Signature Range for you to explore them – it makes a great gift, too. It has been an eventful few weeks for Compass Box, and it was refreshing to hear John’s take on the situation. I’m told Compass Box are preparing a ‘revolutionary manifesto’ as we speak in an attempt to get the laws changes, so watch this space.

Posted in Scotch Whisky, WHISKY & WHISKEY, Whisky Events, Whisky Tasting Notes


Jeff says:

If people have “a right to know” what they’re buying, then producers DO have “an obligation” to tell them – Glaser can’t have it both ways; this is either about what the consumer is entitled to, or it’s just about market positioning and selective disclosure, it can’t be both. Similarly, for all Glaser supposedly “wants” people to know about his products, he withholds minimum age, WHICH NO ONE KEEPS HIM FROM DISCLOSING, on many of his products’ labels. Also, I don’t think that Spice Tree was “banned” by anybody; the SWA, a trade association, NOT a regulatory body, just indicated that they would legally challenge Spice Tree and Compass Box backed down – there was no “banning”, or even any legal resolution as to whether the staves were legal. The situation was milked for all the “buy the ‘illegal’ whisky before it’s gone” publicity possible and then the whole thing went away.

I like the sounds that Glaser makes, but they all have to be taken with a grain of salt; if anyone thinks this ISN’T about marketing, they need to think again. Glaser might be “up for a fight”, but what fighting is he actually doing?

Leave a Reply


Scroll To Top

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this. Find out more