Elements of Islay Pe2: Tasting Notes

5 Comments on Elements of Islay Pe2: Tasting Notes

Yes, it’s finally here! Elements of Islay Pe2 has arrived, and, well, not to blow our own trumpet or anything – but it’s a monster! I tasted this over an hour ago and I can still taste the last of my second watered-down sample (in my world, that’s a good thing).
Anyway, here’s what I (with my admittedly completely biased viewpoint) thought:
Elements of Islay Pe2: Pretty Excellent

Elements of Islay Pe2: Pretty Excellent

Nose: I let the bottle sit open for a few minutes before pouring.  At 59.5%, I usually find most drams need a bit of aeration before I can get the best out of them.
First impressions in the glass: chocolate, very old leather suitcases, balsamico, then a faintly leafy sweetness. Resinous, gammony. Another couple of minutes in the glass reveal rosehip syrup, lovely damp earthy notes, Chinese balloons, syrup, treacle tart, hints of black liquorice. Gamey, minty. Eventually, some woodsmoke, cigar box aromas and some citrus: lemon zest, orangey fruit. Another few minutes of restraint and it’s all apricots, wet flint, plums and dates. Finally, after perhaps 45 minutes, we arrive at a delicious orange, dark chocolate liqueur. In a word: Stunning.
Palate: Pretty full, but very drinkable even at full strength. A wash of coaldust and bonfire woodsmoke, with some dried peat. Chocolate hints. Very lively, it fairly fizzes around the tastebuds. Some spice and mocha. Becomes warming mid-palate as the bonfire peat kicks in. Water tames the fiery roar and lifts the sweetness, while retaining a peaty kick.  In a word: Maelstrom.
Finish: Good length. Becomes drying, with a little chilli heat; as the phenols fade, a honeysuckle sweetness and some fruity notes emerge. In a word: Beautiful.
Comment: Another majestic PE. Any sherry cask of this age (minimum 27 years old) that has only dropped a few points abv is likely to do something pretty special to the spirit inside. You have to like peat and sherry, obviously, but fans of the last Pe1 won’t be disappointed with this – from memory, I think it’s very similar – possibly a little sweeter. I lit a cigarette and asked my glass ‘How was it for you?’.
A quick point on the addition of water to Pe2: In the interests of science, and against my better judgement, I added some water to my original sample. It took a bit of time to accommodate the change, and at first I thought I’d ruined it – brief notes of struck matches and swimming pools, while the palate got sweeter with notes of wet wool (or Serge’s poor wet dogs). However, it recovered after a few minutes.
So I tried adding water to a freshly poured sample, to replicate the likely conditions in the home – much better, but after having had it at cask strength, the dilute version is the equivalent of fighting a dog with no teeth or just watching the dialogue bits in a porn film – pointless. For those with the requisite stiff constitution, my advice is to put your water away. If you’re going to add water, pour a fresh sample – but really this epic spirit should be experienced exactly as nature intended.
Now, before you ask: I’m not at liberty to reveal age, vintage, or distillery – apologies, but this is how it has to be.  What I can tell you is that there’s not very much of this as it’s from a single cask, so if you want one, now’s not the time to dilly-dally.  It’s live now – click here if you want one.  Good Luck everyone!
Posted in Scotch Whisky, Whisky Tasting Notes


Gordon says:

Nah ! never biased……
It’s a pretty good PE if i may say so myself……
More Notes available at http://www.spiritofislay.net/warehouse4/viewtopic.php?f=50&t=1273 if anyone’s interested in them , they are not as good as Tims though……

[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by HO-CHENG YAO and Jolanda Buhrs, The Whisky Exchange. The Whisky Exchange said: Elements of Islay Pe2 Tasting Notes: http://ow.ly/2e35q […]

Linford says:

mmmm looks whiskylicious Tim and very tempting but I just splashed out on the Signatory wine treated butt PE – can I somehow justify buying some more?!

I can also recommend one of those ‘Old Malt Cask’ Douglas Laing sherry butt PEs that come in little 200 ml medicinal bottles at 50%. There’s a little shop not far from me that has a stock and I’m on my second – amazing stuff! (that’s as far as my tasting note vocabulary extends I’m afraid!)

cheers – the blog is a always a good read

Marion Spears says:

Who is casting aspersions on Port Askaig as a single malt?? obviously someone who does not know much about good whisky – and what rubbish about the name – no there is no distillery in Port Askaig but then there is no distillery at Finlaggan either but it didn’t stop Ardbeg from using the name – also Bruichladdich have Octomore – no distillery there either guys!! I f every expression of a single malt must be named for the distillery of origin – who made the rule? Drink Port Askaig and enjoy – it truly is a very good dram – esp my favourite the 17. Slainte!

Gordon says:

I think you’ll find Ardbeg did ‘Kildalton’ (The Parish which Ardbeg is in ) and ‘Airigh Nam Beist’ (An old Farm just up the hill from Ardbeg next to the lower water supply- Loch Iarnan ) .
Finlaggan is a non-attributed Islay single Malt from The Vintage Malt Whisky Company ( http://www.vintagemaltwhisky.com/product-finlaggan.html )

Leave a Reply


Scroll To Top

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this. Find out more